Gozney Arc XL vs Ooni Karu 16: Gas-Only or Multi-Fuel?
9 min read · by Daniel Brooks · Last updated: November 14, 2026
Gozney Arc XL vs Ooni Karu 16 comes down to fuel. The Arc XL is a 16-inch oven that runs on propane only, while the Karu 16 burns wood, charcoal or gas. Both are listed at 950 F maximum, so heat rarely decides the choice.
Gas ovens carry fire and carbon monoxide risks. Follow the manufacturer manual for placement, clearances and gas connection before you cook.
| Pick | Best for | Key fact |
|---|---|---|
| Gozney Arc XL | Gas-only cooks who want one fuel and a simpler setup | Propane burner rated at 17,500 BTU per hour |
| Ooni Karu 16 | Cooks who want wood or charcoal flavor as well as gas | The gas burner is sold separately |
Which Oven Runs on More Fuel?
In Gozney Arc XL vs Ooni Karu 16 terms, the Ooni Karu 16 offers more fuel options, because it runs on wood, charcoal or gas, while the Gozney Arc XL runs on gas only. If you may want wood flavor later, the Karu 16 keeps that option open.
Searches for Gozney Arc XL vs Ooni Karu 16 usually start with one question: which oven fits how I cook? Fuel is the first filter, because it shapes how you start the oven, how you hold heat and which accessories you buy. If you are weighing another Gozney against the same Karu 16, our Gozney Dome against the Karu 16 comparison looks at that pairing.
According to Ooni’s Karu 16 product page, you can cook with wood, charcoal or gas, but the gas option uses a burner that is sold separately. That extra purchase belongs in the total cost of a gas setup.
The Arc XL is built around propane. Gozney’s manual (summarized in our Gozney Arc XL manual guide) describes a propane (LPG) setup with a 17,500 BTU per hour burner, so the Arc XL suits cooks who will only ever use gas.
Choose by the fuel you will use each week:
- Gas only, with quick starts and steady heat: the Arc XL fits this pattern.
- Wood or charcoal flavor now or later: the Karu 16 is the better match.
- Gas and wood both: the Karu 16 covers both, but you must buy the gas burner separately.
Gozney Arc XL vs Ooni Karu 16 Specs Side by Side
The Karu 16 has a 16.7 by 16.7 inch cooking area and weighs 62.6 lb, while the Arc XL weighs 58.5 lb and has a 0.79 inch cordierite stone. Both list a 16-inch pizza size and a 950 F maximum.
| Spec | Gozney Arc XL | Ooni Karu 16 |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel | Gas only (propane) | Wood, charcoal or gas (gas burner sold separately) |
| Pizza size | 16 in | 16 in |
| Cooking area | Not confirmed on a manufacturer page | 16.7 x 16.7 in |
| Outside size | 20.9 x 24.8 x 13.5 in | 32 x 19.6 in footprint, about 33 in tall |
| Weight | 58.5 lb | 62.6 lb |
| Stone | 0.79 in cordierite | 0.6 in cordierite |
| Maximum temperature | 950 F | 950 F |
| Burner rating | 17,500 BTU per hour (manual) | Not confirmed on a manufacturer page |
Gozney Arc XL Propane Outdoor Pizza Oven
- Gozney
- 58.5 pounds
Pros & ConsViewHide
Reasons to buy
- Cooks a 16-inch pizza in about 60 seconds, per the listing
- Reaches and holds 950°F with a removable 20 mm stone
- Precision flame control from the lateral-flame burner
- Compact outside with room to turn a large pizza inside
Reasons to avoid
- Propane only, so no wood or charcoal option
- Premium-priced and heavy at roughly 58 lb
- Stand, cover and mantel are optional extras sold separately
Ooni Karu 16 and Karu 2 Pro Cover
- Ooni
- Prime
Pros & ConsViewHide
Reasons to buy
- Custom fit for the Karu 16 and Karu 2 Pro
- Waterproof polyester with UV and dust protection
- Adjustable straps help stop wind lift
Reasons to avoid
- Fits only the Karu 16 and Karu 2 Pro
- May arrive in Karu 16 packaging even though it also fits the Karu 2 Pro
- Only a small number of Amazon ratings so far
The weight, size, stone and temperature figures come from Pala Pizza Ovens, a review first published July 29, 2024 and updated December 26, 2024. The Karu 16 footprint comes from Ooni’s dimensions sheet, which also gives the cooking area. Check the manufacturer listing before you buy, because specs can change between model years.
Size is a trade-off rather than a clear winner. The Karu 16 is about 32 inches wide, the Arc XL is about 24.8 inches deep, and the Karu weighs about 4 lb more. In a Gozney Arc XL vs Ooni Karu 16 decision, that difference matters mostly if you move the oven often, and our Gozney Arc XL dimensions guide lists the Arc XL size in full. Gozney’s heavier Dome is the other common rival for the Arc XL, and our Arc XL against the Dome guide compares their weight and where each can be used.
How Hot Each Oven Gets
In this Gozney Arc XL vs Ooni Karu 16 comparison, both ovens are listed at 950 F maximum, and Gozney’s manual recommends 600 to 900 F for the main pizza styles. Above 900 F, the manual marks the oven as too hot for cooking.

The Gozney manual sets the Arc XL’s recommended ranges by style:
- New York style: 600 to 700 F (315 to 370 C).
- Roman style: 700 to 800 F (370 to 425 C).
- Neapolitan style: 800 to 900 F (425 to 480 C).
Ooni states that the Karu 16 reaches high heat in 15 minutes, and Pala Pizza Ovens reports that the two models have very similar preheat times. Treat the 15-minute figure as Ooni’s claim, not a test result, and use your own thermometer readings to confirm; our Karu 16 temperature guide explains how this oven holds heat.
The Arc XL manual also warns that the digital thermometer shows error E3 when the oven probe passes 700 C (1,292 F). If that happens, turn the gas burner off and let the oven cool naturally, because rapid cooling can crack the stone floor.
In practice, the temperature question comes down to style. A New York pizza at 600 to 700 F and a Neapolitan pizza at 800 to 900 F ask for different heat, and both ovens are listed at 950 F maximum, so either one can cover that range once it is set up properly.
What Gas Setup Does Each Oven Need?
The Arc XL needs a propane connection at 11 inches water column and a 17,500 BTU per hour burner, while the Karu 16 needs its separate gas burner before it can run on gas. Both setups in this Gozney Arc XL vs Ooni Karu 16 comparison need a clear outdoor space.

The Gozney Arc and Arc XL technical manual says to use the oven outdoors only. It also says never to operate it in enclosed areas, within 1.5 m of any structure, combustible material or gas cylinder, or within 7.5 m of a flammable liquid.
Before you set up the Arc XL, work through these points:
- Confirm your gas type. The manual specifies propane (LPG).
- Keep the required distance from walls, combustible material and gas cylinders.
- Stay outdoors and never leave the oven running unattended.
- Replace the quick-connect cover whenever the gas hose is disconnected.
For the Karu 16, add the gas burner’s price to any gas plan. Ooni’s dimensions sheet lists a 32 by 19.6 inch footprint (see also our Ooni Karu 16 dimensions guide), so measure your space before you buy either oven.
For a Gozney Arc XL vs Ooni Karu 16 choice, gas is where daily use diverges most. The Arc XL is ready once propane is connected and the burner is lit, while the Karu 16 needs its separate burner before the gas option works at all. If neither oven suits your space or budget, alternatives to the Arc XL are compared by size and price.
Gozney Arc XL vs Ooni Karu 16: Which One Should You Buy?
Buy the Gozney Arc XL if you cook only with gas and want a simpler setup, and buy the Ooni Karu 16 if you want wood or charcoal flavor now or later. Fuel usually settles the decision faster than size or heat. A Gozney Arc XL vs Ooni Karu 16 verdict starts there.
Three questions settle most decisions:
- Do you want wood or charcoal? If yes, choose the Karu 16.
- Will you cook only on gas and want the simplest setup? If yes, choose the Arc XL.
- Can you buy the Karu 16 now? Pala Pizza Ovens reported it out of stock on Ooni’s website and Amazon as of December 16, 2024, so check current stock first.
Accessories add to the total. According to the Arc XL manual, the Arc Mantel, Arc Booster and Arc Cover are optional and sold separately, so include them in your budget only if you plan to use them.
Stepping back, a Gozney Arc XL vs Ooni Karu 16 decision is less about brand and more about your weekly routine. If you cook gas pizza most weekends, the simpler path usually wins. If you enjoy tending a fire or want flavor options, the multi-fuel Karu 16 suits you better.

Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Ooni Karu 16 still for sale?
Pala Pizza Ovens reported it out of stock on Ooni’s website and Amazon as of December 16, 2024. Stock varies by country, so a Gozney Arc XL vs Ooni Karu 16 buyer should check the seller in their region first.
Is the Gozney Arc XL vs Ooni Karu 16 comparison fair?
Yes for fuel and size, because both are 16-inch ovens with a 950 F maximum according to Pala Pizza Ovens. It is less certain on price and stock, since the sources are dated and Ooni’s own product page does not list a price.
Can the Gozney Arc XL burn wood?
No. The Arc XL manual covers gas only, with a propane setup and a 17,500 BTU per hour burner. If you want wood or charcoal, the Karu 16 is the model in this comparison that offers them. For Gozney Arc XL vs Ooni Karu 16 buyers, that is the main divide.
Which oven weighs less?
The Arc XL weighs 58.5 lb and the Karu 16 weighs 62.6 lb, according to Pala Pizza Ovens. The gap is small, so fuel should decide the purchase in any Gozney Arc XL vs Ooni Karu 16 comparison.
Does the Karu 16 include a gas burner?
No. Ooni’s product page says the gas burner is sold separately, so budget for it if you want gas. In any Gozney Arc XL vs Ooni Karu 16 budget, that extra purchase changes the total.
What is the highest safe temperature on the Arc XL?
The manual marks temperatures above 900 F as too hot. Its thermometer error E3 appears when the probe passes 700 C (1,292 F), so let the oven cool naturally if you see it.
Gozney Arc XL vs Ooni Karu 16 is a fuel decision first. If you already cook on gas and want one simple fuel path, the Arc XL is the cleaner pick. If you want wood or charcoal flavor, or you may switch fuels later, the Karu 16 gives you that flexibility. Check current stock and the manual before you buy.
8 min readReviews & VersusOoni Karu 16 vs Ooni Karu 2 Pro: Which Multi-Fuel Oven to ChooseUpdated Nov 14, 2026
7 min readReviews & VersusOoni Koda 2 Max vs Gozney Arc XL: Which Gas Oven Fits Your SpaceUpdated Nov 14, 2026
7 min readReviews & VersusGozney Arc XL vs Ooni Karu 2 Pro: Which Pizza Oven Fits Your CookingUpdated Nov 14, 2026
9 min readReviews & VersusGozney Arc vs Ooni Koda 16: Which Gas Pizza Oven Should You Buy?Updated Nov 14, 2026
8 min readReviews & VersusGozney Arc XL vs Gozney Dome: Size, Fuel and Fit ComparedUpdated Nov 14, 2026
9 min readReviews & VersusBest Ooni Karu 16 Alternatives for Wood, Gas and Charcoal CookingUpdated Nov 14, 2026