Ditalini Substitute: Best Pasta Swaps by Dish
6 min read · by Grace Lin · Last updated: November 13, 2026
The best ditalini substitute is another small, short tube pasta, such as tubetti, elbow macaroni or small orzo-style pastina. Choose by dish: tubetti is the closest match, elbow macaroni works in baked and cold dishes, and pastina suits soup. Cook each substitute by the package time, because small shapes can go from firm to soft quickly.
What Makes Ditalini Different?
Ditalini is a very short, hollow tube, about the size of a thimble, and its name means “small thimbles” in Italian. Because the pieces are so small, they sit neatly on a spoon and hold smooth sauces well.

Ditalini is also known as tubettini and, in some areas, as “salad macaroni.” The Wikipedia entry on ditalini describes it as very short macaroni, which is why most substitutes come from the same family of small tubes. Because the shape is so compact, home cooks often reach for it when a soup or a cold salad needs a small, tidy pasta that fits on a spoon with the beans, peas or vegetables around it. That same compact size is what makes a swap so easy to plan.
Which Ditalini Substitute Works Best in Soup?
For soup, a small pastina such as orzo or acini di pepe is the most practical swap, because both cook directly in the broth and stay small enough for a spoon.
Ditalini is traditionally used in pasta e fagioli, the bean and pasta soup from Italy. Minestrone, vegetable soup and chicken soup also suit small shapes, and the DeLallo guide to ditalini lists several of these soups as typical uses.
- Tubetti: the closest match in size and shape, so cook it by the package time.
- Acini di pepe or orzo: small pastina that absorbs broth; check the package for the cooking time.
- Small shells or small elbow macaroni: works in thicker, chunkier soups.
What Is the Best Ditalini Substitute in Pasta Dishes and Salads?
For warm pasta dishes and cold salads, elbow macaroni is the most common replacement, since it is similar in length and holds sauce in the same way.
Tubetti is the best match when you want the same look in a finished dish. Elbow macaroni is slightly curved rather than straight, so the texture of a macaroni salad will be a little different, but the dish will still work.

| Substitute | Best for | Watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Tubetti | Soup, pasta e fagioli, smooth sauces | Harder to find in some stores |
| Elbow macaroni | Baked dishes, macaroni salad, mac and cheese | Curved shape gives a different bite |
| Orzo or acini di pepe | Brothy soups | Can turn mushy if left in hot broth too long |
How Should You Adjust Cooking Time When You Swap?
Cook any ditalini substitute by its own package time, not the time printed for ditalini, because shapes of similar size can still differ in thickness.
Pull the pasta a minute or two before the package time if it will keep cooking in a sauce or a hot soup. This is the step that most often causes a swap to turn soft.
How to Test a Ditalini Substitute Before Cooking for Guests
Testing a ditalini substitute at home is a simple way to avoid a disappointing dish. Cook a small handful of the substitute on its own, taste it, and check the texture against the package time. If it is too firm for your soup, let it simmer a minute or two longer. If it turns soft in a salad, rinse it under cold water sooner next time.
A ditalini substitute also needs to match the amount of sauce or broth in the recipe. Tubes hold more sauce than pastina, so a baked dish may need slightly less liquid than the recipe calls for. Pastina in a brothy soup keeps absorbing liquid as it sits, so add it close to serving time and loosen the soup with a splash of broth before you serve.
Keep the rest of the recipe the same when you test. Use the same salt, the same onion and the same beans or peas, so the only change is the pasta. That makes it much easier to tell whether the ditalini substitute caused any difference in the finished dish.
Size matters more than name. A pasta that is roughly the same length and width as ditalini will behave similarly, while a long shape or a wide ribbon will change the spoonful and the mouthfeel. When you are unsure, compare the shape on the package with the size of a grain of rice or a thimble, and choose the closest match.
Salt the cooking water well, as you would for any pasta, and taste the water before you add the substitute. Well-seasoned water gives a small pasta flavor from the start, which matters more in soup and salad than in a heavy sauce.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use elbow macaroni instead of ditalini?
Yes, for most baked dishes, macaroni salads and mac and cheese. In soup it works too, but the curved shape holds less broth than a straight tube.
What is the closest ditalini substitute?
Tubetti, also called tubettini, is the closest match because it is a similar short tube. It is less common than elbow macaroni, so check the pasta aisle or an Italian grocer.
Can orzo replace ditalini in soup?
Orzo works well in brothy soups, but it is a rice-shaped pastina rather than a tube, so the texture will be lighter. Add it near the end of cooking so it does not swell too much.
Does the swap change the cooking time?
It can. Different shapes have different thickness, so follow the time on the package of your ditalini substitute and test a piece a minute before it is due. Once the pasta is tender, drain it promptly so it does not keep cooking in the pot.
When you need a ditalini substitute, pick the shape that fits the dish. Tubetti is the nearest match, elbow macaroni handles baked and cold dishes, and a small pastina fits brothy soups. Cook each one by its own package time, and pull it a little early if it will keep cooking in a hot sauce or broth.
6 min readLearnCavatappi Substitute: Best Pasta Swaps for Every DishUpdated Nov 13, 2026
6 min readLearnLinguine Substitute: Best Pasta Swaps for Any SauceUpdated Nov 13, 2026
6 min readLearnRotini Substitute: Fusilli and 4 Other Pasta SwapsUpdated Nov 13, 2026
6 min readLearnBucatini Substitute: Best Pasta Swaps and How to Use ThemUpdated Nov 13, 2026
6 min readLearnPaccheri Substitute: Rigatoni, Mezzi Paccheri and Other SwapsUpdated Nov 13, 2026
5 min readLearnOrzo Substitute: Best Swaps by Ratio and Cook TimeUpdated Nov 13, 2026