Paccheri Substitute: Rigatoni, Mezzi Paccheri and Other Swaps
6 min read · by Grace Lin · Last updated: November 13, 2026
The closest paccheri substitute is rigatoni, because both are large tube pastas that hold chunky sauce well. Paccheri is shorter and wider than rigatoni, so if you want a smaller tube with the same kind of bite, mezzi paccheri is the better match. Pick the swap by the sauce you plan to serve and by the size of the tube, not only by the name on the box.
Why Rigatoni Is the Closest Paccheri Substitute
Rigatoni is the swap most cooks reach for first, because it is also a large, hollow tube with ridges on the outside. Its shape lets thick sauce settle into the opening and along the grooves, which is the same job paccheri does at the table.

The main difference is size. Paccheri is shorter and wider than rigatoni, according to the shape comparison from Delightedcooking. That means a rigatoni tube will fit a spoonful of ragù, but it will feel slimmer on the fork and hold less filling. If your recipe depends on a wide opening, choose the widest rigatoni you can find and check the box for the diameter.
Rigatoni and paccheri behave alike in a tomato or meat sauce, so the swap works well for a weeknight pot of ragù. Stuffed dishes are different. A rigatoni tube is usually too narrow for a generous filling, so keep the stuffed recipe for a tube made for that job.
Other Tube Pastas to Try
If rigatoni is too long or too narrow, two other tube shapes from the same family are worth a look: the smaller mezzi paccheri and the ridged version called paccheri millerighe.

Mezzi Paccheri
Mezzi paccheri is the smaller option listed by The Pasta Project in its paccheri guide. It keeps the wide tube shape but cuts it shorter, so it suits a bowl that needs a bit more bite per forkful. Use it when your recipe calls for paccheri but you want a less bulky piece.
Paccheri Millerighe
Paccheri millerighe is the ridged version of the same large tube. The ridges give a rougher surface, which can help a thinner sauce cling. If you can only find a smooth tube, a slightly thicker sauce will do the same job.
How to Choose the Right Swap
The right substitute depends on what the dish needs: a tube that holds chunky meat sauce, a smaller piece for a light tossed dish, or a shape that can carry a baked topping.
- For a thick meat ragù or bolognese, use rigatoni or another large ridged tube.
- For a smaller, lighter bowl, use mezzi paccheri.
- For a baked, lasagna-style dish, choose a sturdy tube and follow the baking time in your recipe, because the sources do not give one number for every swap.
- For a stuffed dish, look at manicotti tubes, which The Pasta Project describes as a close cousin of stuffed paccheri.
Cooking Tips When You Swap
A swap changes the timing, so do not cook by habit. Read the cook time on the box you actually bought, then taste a piece a minute or two before it is due. Large tubes can look cooked on the outside while the center is still firm.
Salt the cooking water well, and save a cup of the cooking water before you drain the pasta. A splash of it helps a thick sauce coat the tubes evenly. Fill the tube only if the recipe asks for it, and keep the sauce warm so the pasta does not cool before it reaches the plate.
What Makes Paccheri Different From Other Tubes
Paccheri pasta is a large, hollow tube from Campania in southern Italy, especially Naples. The name comes from the Neapolitan word paccharia, which is usually linked to the word for slaps. Some sources say the name refers to the slapping sound the tube makes when it is eaten, but that is a story rather than a settled fact.
Wikipedia notes that paccheri split open into a flat sheet as they are eaten, which is part of why the shape feels different from short pasta. That wide opening is also why cooks often fill paccheri and bake them, so a substitute that is too narrow may not suit a stuffed recipe.
Smooth paccheri is the more common form, and a ridged version called paccheri millerighe is also sold. Some cooks call the same tube schiaffoni. In Campania the tube is also listed under the name tufoli rigati. If you see one of these names on a box, it is worth reading the size on the package before you choose a swap.
The Pasta Project describes paccheri as a shape for rich, robust sauces, and it also pairs the tube with delicate seafood. For a substitute, that means you can often keep the sauce you planned and change only the tube, as long as the new shape is large enough to hold the same amount of sauce per bite.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is paccheri the same as rigatoni?
No, but they are close. Both are large tubes, and rigatoni is the closest swap. Paccheri is shorter and wider, so the two shapes look and feel a little different on the plate.
What is the smaller version of paccheri?
The smaller option is mezzi paccheri. It keeps the wide tube shape in a shorter cut, which suits lighter dishes.
Can I use manicotti instead of paccheri?
For stuffed dishes, yes, because the two are close cousins. For tossed sauces, check the tube size first, since manicotti is usually used for baked dishes.
Does paccheri millerighe cook differently from smooth paccheri?
The ridged version is the same tube with a rougher surface. Use the package time for the shape you bought, and check the center of a piece before draining.
Rigatoni is the easiest paccheri swap for most weeknight sauces, and mezzi paccheri is the choice when you want a smaller bite. Match the tube to the sauce, cook to the package time, and keep a little pasta water on hand. That combination gives you a dish that tastes close to the original without a special trip to the store.
6 min readLearnRotini Substitute: Fusilli and 4 Other Pasta SwapsUpdated Nov 13, 2026
9 min readLearnPaccheri vs Rigatoni: Key Differences and Which Sauce FitsUpdated Nov 6, 2026
7 min readLearnPaccheri Pasta: Sauces, Substitutes and Homemade GuideUpdated Nov 6, 2026
5 min readLearnGemelli Substitute: Fusilli and 3 Other Twisted PastasUpdated Nov 13, 2026
6 min readLearnCasarecce Substitute: Fusilli, Rotini and Other TwistsUpdated Nov 13, 2026
6 min readLearnCapellini Substitute: Angel Hair and 3 Other Thin PastasUpdated Nov 13, 2026