De Cecco vs Barilla: Which Pasta Wins the Taste Test?
8 min read · by Hannah Cole · Last updated: November 15, 2026
De Cecco vs Barilla comes down to one independent taste test, which put De Cecco No. 12 spaghetti first and Barilla No. 5 last. The 2015 Swiss TV test covered nine supermarket brands, and it is one test, not a final verdict on every shape.
Both are long-running Italian pasta makers that differ in age, ownership and bronze-die claims. Start from the same shape, then compare the unit price before you decide.
De Cecco vs Barilla at a Glance
Barilla is the older company, founded in 1877 as a bakery in Parma, while De Cecco was founded in 1886 in Fara San Martino, Abruzzo. The companies also differ in scale: Wikipedia calls Barilla the world’s largest pasta producer, and it lists De Cecco as the third-largest as of 2013.
The table below sets out the facts that could be confirmed for De Cecco vs Barilla. Ownership and scale are the clearest differences, and the price row stays open because no current shelf price was confirmed for either brand.
| Factor | De Cecco | Barilla |
|---|---|---|
| Founded | 1886, Fara San Martino (Abruzzo) | 1877, as a bakery in Parma |
| Ownership | Family-owned, with 24 shareholders from the third to fifth generations | Privately held; control passed to W. R. Grace in 1971 and returned to the family in 1979 |
| Scale (per Wikipedia) | Third-largest pasta producer, as of 2013 | World’s largest pasta producer |
| Production sites | Not confirmed here | 30, half of them in Italy |
| Shelf price | Not confirmed here | Not confirmed here |
Founding, ownership and scale details come from the Barilla Group Wikipedia entry, which also gives the production-site count.

De Cecco vs Barilla in the 2015 Swiss Taste Test
In a 2015 Swiss TV test, De Cecco No. 12 spaghetti scored 4.16 out of 5 and placed first, while Barilla No. 5 scored 2.25 and placed last. The test came from the Swiss programme A bon entendeur, and the article about it was published on 15 September 2015.

Nine spaghetti brands sold in supermarkets were tested, and the article says nearly all were made in Italy. Tasting was anonymous, and each brand was cooked for the time printed on its package. The panel included two restaurant operators, a specialized food journalist and a television gastronomy host who has written a book on pasta.
- Products: De Cecco No. 12 and Barilla No. 5 spaghetti
- Scores: 4.16 and 2.25 out of 5
- Criteria: cooking resistance, tenacity and overall quality
- Venue: a restaurant in Geneva
The article did not publish a score breakdown, so the two totals are the only numbers available. For De Cecco vs Barilla, the result is one data point from one shape and one run, not a full ranking. A similar brand matchup is covered in Rummo vs De Cecco.
Two Tests Point the Same Way
A January 2012 Altroconsumo test of 22 brands ranked De Cecco No. 12 third and Barilla No. 5 sixteenth, according to Il Fatto Alimentare’s spaghetti test report.
Both tests put De Cecco ahead of Barilla, but they used different brand sets, different years and different product numbers. Two results in the same direction carry more weight than one, though neither shows how the pasta cooks with your own sauce.
The 2012 ranking also shows the order is not fixed. In that test De Cecco finished behind Voiello and Buitoni, so the leader depends on the year and the field of brands.
Read together, the two tests give a clearer picture of De Cecco vs Barilla than either one does alone. Neither test ranks the full shelf, so treat both as useful evidence rather than a final ranking.
Ingredients and Bronze Dies: What Is Confirmed
Italian rules for plain dried pasta allow only durum wheat semolina and water, so ingredients rarely separate De Cecco vs Barilla. Under the regulated Pasta category, up to 3% soft-wheat flour is also allowed.

The die is the shaped opening in the extruder that the dough is pushed through, and it sets the shape of the pasta. Some comparison articles say De Cecco uses bronze dies for all its shapes, while Barilla uses them only for its Collezione line. Those articles also say a rougher bronze-cut surface holds sauce better. This article did not confirm those claims on either brand’s own site, so treat them as claims. For background on the term, see what bronze-cut pasta is.
For De Cecco vs Barilla on texture, check the package for a bronze-die label before you buy. A label on the box is a firmer source than a general brand statement or a comparison article.
What Each Brand Costs and How to Compare
Price is the one factor this article could not confirm for either brand, so compare the current unit price for the same shape. Some comparison sites describe De Cecco as the pricier option, but no current shelf price for either brand was checked here.
Unit price is the shelf price divided by the package weight. Use it rather than the sticker price, because a bigger box can have a higher total price and a lower price per ounce. For De Cecco vs Barilla, run the same check on both boxes:
- Match the shape: spaghetti against spaghetti
- Convert both to price per ounce or per pound
- Note the date and the store for each price
- Check that both packages list the same net weight
Price comparisons go stale quickly. Record the date of each De Cecco vs Barilla price so a later comparison stays fair, and repeat the check before a large purchase.
Who Should Pick De Cecco and Who Should Pick Barilla
Pick De Cecco if the 2015 spaghetti result matters most to you. Pick Barilla if its scale, its production network or a lower price at your store is the deciding factor.
If you are choosing for a family that eats pasta every week, shelf price per serving matters more than a single score, because you will buy the box again and again.
- De Cecco fits buyers who cook long pasta with sauce and want the top spaghetti result from the 2015 test.
- Barilla fits buyers who value a large producer with 30 production sites and 24.5% of the Italian market, according to Wikipedia.
- Either brand fits a cook who buys the same shape each week and wants consistent results.
The choice narrows when you test both brands yourself. Cook each spaghetti for the time printed on its package, taste them at the same point, and note which one keeps its bite. A side-by-side cook of De Cecco vs Barilla in your own kitchen gives you a result that matters more to you than any broadcast score.
This comparison covers spaghetti only. Fusilli, fettuccine or other shapes may rank differently, so do not let one shape decide your whole pantry. Our spaghetti pasta guide explains the shape itself.
De Cecco Spaghetti No. 12 Pasta, 16 Oz
- De Cecco
- 16 oz
- Prime
Pros & ConsViewHide
Reasons to buy
- Slow-dried durum wheat spaghetti, the No. 12 cut
- Low shelf price per 16 oz box
- 83% of 3K Amazon ratings are 5-star
Reasons to avoid
- Single box means more reorders for a weekly cook
- Price can change by store and seller
Barilla Spaghetti Pasta, 16 oz. Box - Non-GMO
- Barilla Pasta
- 16 oz
- Prime
Pros & ConsViewHide
Reasons to buy
- Widely sold, non-GMO durum wheat semolina spaghetti
- Budget-friendly 16 oz box
- 87% of about 19.7K Amazon ratings are 5-star
Reasons to avoid
- The listing does not say bronze die, so sauce cling may be lower
- Everyday texture rather than a specialty pasta
What This Comparison Does Not Cover
No single source settles De Cecco vs Barilla for every shopper. Current prices, the full range of shapes and each brand’s bronze-die statements remain outside what this article could confirm. The two taste tests date from 2012 and 2015, and neither reports protein, sodium or cooking water, so they cannot settle nutrition.
To close those gaps, check the current shelf price on the store page, read the bronze-die and ingredient statements on the box, and compare the nutrition panel on the exact package you plan to buy. The brand websites could not be checked for this article, so the package is the reliable source.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Is Better, De Cecco or Barilla?
On the 2015 Swiss TV test, De Cecco vs Barilla favored De Cecco. De Cecco No. 12 spaghetti scored 4.16 out of 5 and placed first, while Barilla No. 5 placed last at 2.25. One test is not a final verdict, so cook the shape you buy most often before you decide between them.
Is Barilla the Bigger Pasta Company?
Yes, by the figures on Wikipedia, which calls Barilla the world’s largest pasta producer and lists De Cecco as third-largest as of 2013. Both figures are dated, so check current company reports before you quote them.
Are De Cecco and Barilla Made in Italy?
Both companies started in Italy, De Cecco in Fara San Martino and Barilla in Parma. Barilla runs 30 production sites, and Wikipedia says half are in Italy, so not every Barilla box comes from an Italian plant. Check the package for the plant location of the De Cecco vs Barilla product you buy.
Which Shape Should I Use to Compare Them?
Compare the same shape. The 2015 Swiss test used spaghetti, so spaghetti against spaghetti is the fairest way to compare De Cecco vs Barilla. A different shape can rank differently, so run the test on the pasta you cook most often.
Does Bronze-Die Pasta Hold Sauce Better?
Some brands and comparison sites say so, because a rougher surface can grip sauce. This article did not confirm that claim with a taste test or a brand page, so treat it as a claim until you cook both and compare.
For most home cooks, the sensible step is to buy the same spaghetti from each brand and cook both with the same sauce. For De Cecco vs Barilla, the 2015 test favored De Cecco, but your store price and your own taste should make the final call. More brand matchups are in the gear and pantry guides.
10 min readGear & PantryIs De Cecco Pasta Good? A Review of Taste, Texture and QualityUpdated Nov 10, 2026
9 min readGear & PantryRummo vs De Cecco: Which Dried Pasta Brand Should You Buy?Updated Nov 7, 2026
9 min readGear & PantryBarilla Al Bronzo Review: Is Bronze-Die Pasta Worth It?Updated Nov 9, 2026
8 min readGear & PantryMutti Passata Review: Ingredients, Taste and ValueUpdated Nov 8, 2026
9 min readGear & PantryBest Jarred Pizza Sauce: How to Choose One That Tastes FreshUpdated Nov 10, 2026
8 min readGear & PantryBest Pecorino Romano: How to Pick a Wedge That Tastes RightUpdated Nov 12, 2026