KitchenAid Pasta Roller vs Extruder: Which Attachment to Buy
5 min read · by Daniel Brooks · Last updated: November 13, 2026
KitchenAid pasta roller vs extruder comes down to the shape you want. The roller makes flat sheets and cut noodles, while the extruder pushes dough through shaped discs. Choose the roller for lasagna sheets, fettuccine, and spaghetti with less hassle, and choose the extruder if you want macaroni, fusilli, rigatoni, or bucatini.
KitchenAid Pasta Roller vs Extruder: What the Roller Makes
The roller is built for sheet pasta. Homelization says it makes flat sheets for lasagna noodles, tortillas, perogies, and thin-crust pizza dough.
With the cutter set, the same roller also makes spaghetti and fettuccine. Homelization calls the roller simpler and easier to use than the press.
You flatten portions of dough and pass them through the roller, folding and re-rolling until the sheets are uniform. The roller has eight thickness settings.
KitchenAid Pasta Roller vs Extruder: What the Extruder Makes
The extruder is built for shaped pasta. Homelization says it makes shapes from six discs, including spaghetti, fusilli, bucatini, rigatoni, and large and small macaroni.
The extruder has no lasagna disc, so it is not the right attachment for sheet pasta. If lasagna is your main goal, the roller is the better choice.
The extruder is the more specialized tool. Its six discs cover a range of shapes, but it has no lasagna disc and no sheet setting, so the two attachments do not overlap much.
Homelization calls the press expensive and says some parts must be hand-washed, which can be tricky when dough gets stuck. It also says mastering the technique takes practice, and some users want more disc variety.
A reviewer on Ultimate Food Geek found that the extruder makes round spaghetti rather than the square-edged noodles a roller produces, and that its built-in slicer cuts the pasta as it comes out.
KitchenAid Pasta Roller vs Extruder Side by Side
The two attachments suit different cooks. The roller is easier to learn, while the extruder gives more shapes but takes more practice.
A simple rule helps here. If you start with dough for sheets and cut noodles, the roller fits the job. If your goal is macaroni, fusilli, or rigatoni, the extruder is the attachment built for those shapes.
| Feature | Pasta roller | Pasta extruder |
|---|---|---|
| Main output | Flat sheets, plus spaghetti and fettuccine with the cutter set | Spaghetti, fusilli, bucatini, rigatoni, and macaroni |
| Shaping method | Flatten, fold and re-roll, then cut | Feed small batches through a disc; a built-in wire cutter sets the length |
| Settings or choices | Eight thickness settings | Six discs |
| Learning curve | Simpler, according to the review | Takes practice to master, according to the review |

In the reviewer’s test, dough went into the extruder right after kneading without a rest, and the whole process from dough to extrusion took about 15 minutes.
Which Attachment Is Easier to Clean?
Cleanup is where the two attachments differ most. The roller has its own hassles, while the extruder needs a dry-cleaning routine. Plan for cleanup time after each batch, whichever attachment you choose.
Homelization notes that the roller screws can loosen and need tightening, and that some users find spaghetti dough hard to separate from the cutter. It also says that wiping with a damp cloth may not fully sanitize the roller.
The extruder must be taken apart, and some parts must be hand-washed. Ultimate Food Geek says to let the dough dry overnight, pick it off, and brush the parts clean, and it warns not to wash the unit.

Does Your Mixer Model Matter?
The extruder attaches to KitchenAid stand mixers, but the review’s test was done on a Professional 600 rated at 575 watts. The reviewer noted that the less powerful Artisan, rated at 325 watts, might perform differently, but did not test it.
If you already own an Artisan, treat the wattage gap as a question to answer before you buy, since the review did not measure how the extruder performs on that model.
Check your mixer model before you buy. The review tested the extruder on one stand mixer only, so confirm that your model matches before you order.
Which KitchenAid Attachment Should You Choose?
Choose the roller if you want flat noodles, lasagna sheets, or a simpler set of tools. Choose the extruder if you want shaped pasta and can accept the extra cleanup and the higher cost. Either way, the roller is the simpler first buy for most home cooks.
Both reviews describe a higher price for the extruder, and homelization says some buyers find the roller cutter set expensive as well. Compare the current listings before you buy.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the KitchenAid pasta roller make macaroni?
No. The roller makes sheets, plus spaghetti and fettuccine with the cutter set. Macaroni is one of the shapes the extruder makes.
Does the pasta extruder make lasagna sheets?
No. Homelization says the extruder has no lasagna disc, so use the roller for lasagna sheets.
Is the pasta extruder hard to use?
Homelization says mastering the technique takes practice. Ultimate Food Geek’s reviewer found it easy, and the whole process from dough to extrusion took about 15 minutes.
Which KitchenAid pasta attachment is better for beginners?
Homelization calls the roller simpler and easier to use than the press, so it is the easier starting point for most beginners.
Is the KitchenAid pasta roller good for lasagna?
Homelization lists lasagna noodles among the roller’s sheet uses, and the extruder has no lasagna disc, so the roller is the attachment for lasagna sheets.
Does the dough need to rest before extruding?
The reviewer put the dough into the extruder right after kneading, without a rest. Follow the attachment’s own guidance if it differs.
If you make sheet pasta, the roller is the simpler choice. If you want shaped pasta such as macaroni or fusilli, the extruder is the attachment to consider, once you have confirmed your mixer model and accepted the cleanup routine.
9 min readReviews & VersusKitchenAid Pasta Roller: Set, Specs and Who Should Buy ItUpdated Nov 15, 2026
8 min readReviews & VersusKitchenAid Pasta Extruder: Shapes, Speeds and Buying GuideUpdated Nov 15, 2026
9 min readReviews & VersusKitchenAid Pasta Maker: What the Attachments Do and How to Use ThemUpdated Nov 15, 2026
6 min readReviews & VersusKitchenAid KSMPRA Pasta Roller and Cutter Set GuideUpdated Nov 13, 2026
8 min readReviews & VersusKitchenAid Pasta Roller Warranty: Coverage, Length and ClaimsUpdated Nov 10, 2026
8 min readReviews & VersusImperia Pasta Machine: Models, Roller Range and Who Should BuyUpdated Nov 15, 2026