Penne Substitute: 5 Pasta Shapes That Work Well
6 min read · by Grace Lin · Last updated: November 13, 2026
The best penne substitute options are rigatoni, ziti, mezze penne, fusilli and cavatappi, because each one is a short, sturdy pasta shape with ridges or a hollow centre that holds sauce. Penne is a tube with angled ends, so a penne substitute of similar size and shape will work in most recipes. Pick the one that matches the texture your dish needs and adjust the cooking time to the package.
What Makes Penne a Good Sauce Pasta
Penne gets its name from the Italian word for “quills” and its angled cut. The tube shape traps sauce inside, and the grooves on ridged penne (penne rigate) grip thick sauces. Smooth penne (penne lisce) has a slicker surface, so it works better with thinner sauces that need to coat the outside. Knowing these two traits helps you choose a substitute, because the best match keeps the same sauce-holding ability.

According to the DeLallo guide to penne, the grooves help the pasta hold sauce, which makes the ridged version a practical choice for chunky sauces. The same guide notes that penne is usually cooked for about 10 to 12 minutes, but it advises checking the pasta before the package time is reached. DeLallo’s penne guide covers the ridges and cooking notes in more detail.
The penne entry on Wikipedia describes the tube shape with angled ends. When you look for a substitute, match that shape first, then check the surface texture and the size of the hole.
Best Penne Substitute Shapes by Type
Five shapes are the most practical penne substitute choices in a typical kitchen. Rigatoni is the closest match, while ziti, mezze penne, fusilli and cavatappi each bring a slightly different bite. Read the list below and match the shape to the sauce you already have.

- Rigatoni: A larger ridged tube with straight-cut ends. It is the nearest match for penne rigate and holds chunky sauce well. Use it for baked pasta and meat sauces.
- Ziti: A smooth tube that is often sold for baked dishes. It is a good stand-in for penne lisce, especially in a baked casserole with cheese.
- Mezze penne: A half-length version of penne. It cooks a little faster and works well in soups, salads and smaller portions.
- Fusilli: A spiral shape with deep grooves. It catches pesto and light cream sauces in the twists, so it suits salads and quick skillet dinners.
- Cavatappi: A corkscrew tube with a hollow centre. It is a strong choice for macaroni-style dishes and creamy sauces that need to cling.
Matching a Penne Substitute to Your Sauce
The sauce decides which penne substitute will work best. A chunky tomato sauce with meat or vegetables needs a wide ridged tube, so rigatoni is the natural pick. A smooth, thin sauce such as a light butter or olive oil sauce slides off wide tubes, so a smaller shape or a spiral is a better fit.
Pesto and cream sauces are a special case. Pesto clings to the twists of fusilli, while a cream sauce settles into the hollow of cavatappi. For a baked dish with a thick béchamel or cheese sauce, ziti is a dependable penne substitute because the smooth tube fills evenly and stays intact in the oven.
How to Swap Penne in a Recipe
Swapping pasta is simple, but a few adjustments keep the dish balanced. Start by weighing or measuring the dry pasta that your recipe calls for, then use the same amount of the substitute. Cook the substitute in salted water, and taste it before you drain it, since cook times differ between shapes.
- Check the package for the cooking time of the substitute, then start testing 2 minutes before that time.
- Keep the sauce quantity the same. A tube or spiral with more surface area may need a splash more sauce.
- Save a half cup of the cooking water before draining. Adding it to the sauce helps the new shape coat evenly.
- If the dish is baked, undercook the pasta slightly, because it will keep cooking in the oven.
Substitutes for Baked and Cold Dishes
Penne is often used in baked pasta and cold salads, and the right substitute depends on how the dish is served. Sturdy shapes that hold their form after cooling work best in salads, while tubes with a wide opening suit baked casseroles.
| Substitute | Best use | Watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Rigatoni | Baked pasta, meat sauce | Larger, so it may take longer to cook |
| Ziti | Casseroles with cheese | Smooth surface grips less sauce |
| Mezze penne | Soups and salads | Cooks faster, so start testing early |
| Fusilli | Pesto and cold salads | Thick sauces can sit in the top spirals |
| Cavatappi | Creamy and macaroni-style dishes | Hollow centre needs enough sauce |
For a cold pasta salad, cook the substitute until it is just tender, rinse it under cool water and dress it while it is still slightly warm. For a baked dish, check the oven instructions in your recipe, because the pasta absorbs liquid as it bakes. If the package does not list a time for your chosen shape, check the manufacturer’s instructions on the box.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the closest substitute for penne?
Rigatoni is the closest match because it is also a ridged tube with a similar cut. Ziti is the best choice if you want a smooth tube instead.
Can I use fusilli instead of penne?
Yes. Fusilli works well with pesto, light cream sauces and cold salads. It is less suited to thick meat sauces that need to fill a hollow tube.
Does the cooking time change when I substitute penne?
Usually, yes. Each shape has its own time, so check the package of the substitute and start tasting before the stated time. Check the package for the exact time, since brands vary.
Is mezze penne the same as penne?
Mezze penne is a shorter version of penne with the same tube shape. It is a direct penne substitute in most recipes, though it cooks a little faster and suits smaller portions and soups.
Is rigatoni a good penne substitute for baked dishes?
Yes. Rigatoni is a sturdy ridged tube that holds meat sauce and cheese in a casserole. Because it is larger than penne, check the package for the cooking time and undercook it slightly before baking.
Choosing a penne substitute comes down to shape, surface and cooking time. Rigatoni is the safest swap for most sauces, while fusilli and cavatappi suit lighter or creamy dishes. Test the pasta a couple of minutes before the package time, keep some cooking water on hand, and your dish will turn out well.
5 min readLearnRigatoni Substitute: 4 Pasta Shapes That Work Just as WellUpdated Nov 13, 2026
6 min readLearnMacaroni Substitute: Best Pasta Shapes That WorkUpdated Nov 13, 2026
6 min readLearnRadiatori Substitute: Pasta Shapes That Hold Sauce Like It DoesUpdated Nov 13, 2026
6 min readLearnSpaghetti Substitute: 4 Easy Options That Work With Any SauceUpdated Nov 13, 2026
5 min readLearnBest Sauce for Orzo: Light, Glossy Options That Coat WellUpdated Nov 13, 2026
6 min readLearnBest Sauce for Linguine: Light Sauces That Cling WellUpdated Nov 13, 2026