Macaroni Substitute: Best Pasta Shapes That Work
6 min read · by Grace Lin · Last updated: November 13, 2026
The best macaroni substitute is another short, hollow or ridged pasta of similar size. Small shells, cavatappi, gnocchi and cavatelli are the most common swaps, and most of them work in mac and cheese or any dish that calls for elbow macaroni. Pick a shape that is close in length and thickness, then check the cooking time on the box.
Your choice depends on the sauce and the dish. A thick cheese sauce needs a shape with ridges or cups to trap it, while a cold pasta salad can use almost any short tube. The sections below explain the closest swaps, how to match them to a sauce, and how to adjust the cooking.
Which Pasta Is the Closest Match to Macaroni?
Small shells and cavatappi are the two closest everyday substitutes for elbow macaroni, because both are short and curved enough to hold a cheese sauce.
Cavatappi resembles elbow macaroni most closely, but it has a corkscrew shape, so it is slightly longer and more twisted. Small shell pasta is the most common swap in classic mac and cheese recipes, and it works well because its cups catch the sauce.
Gomiti is a close cousin of macaroni. Some gomiti are ridged while macaroni is usually smooth, so the texture differs a little, but the size is similar. The pasta swap guide at Reluctant Gourmet lists small shells as the direct macaroni match.

How Do You Match a Substitute to the Sauce?
Match the pasta to the sauce by thickness and surface: heavy sauces need sturdy shapes, and chunky sauces need pieces that can hold bits of food.
The same guide gives a simple rule: ridged, hollow or cupped shapes hold more sauce than smooth ones. For a thick cheese sauce, shapes such as orecchiette and campanelle are useful because their cups and ridges collect the sauce.
- Cheese sauce: small shells, cavatappi or orecchiette.
- Chunky tomato or meat sauce: campanelle, gemelli or cavatelli, which trap small pieces.
- Cold pasta salad: ditalini or small tubes, which hold a dressing and stay firm when chilled.
What Changes When You Swap the Pasta?
The main change is cooking time, because pasta shapes of similar size can still differ by a few minutes in the pot.
The guide notes that shapes in the same category can vary by 4 to 6 minutes, so the package time is the best starting point. Pull the pasta 1 to 2 minutes before the package time if it will keep cooking in a hot sauce or in the oven.
Swap within the same family. Use a tube for a tube, a shell for a shell and a long pasta for a long pasta. A thick tube and a thin tube behave very differently in the same sauce, so avoid mixing them without adjusting the amount of sauce.

| Substitute | Shape | Best use |
|---|---|---|
| Small shells | Cupped | Mac and cheese |
| Cavatappi | Corkscrew tube | Baked pasta with cheese |
| Orecchiette | Ridged cup | Thick cheese sauce |
| Ditalini | Short tube | Soups and cold salads |
How Do You Use a Macaroni Substitute in Mac and Cheese?
When you use a macaroni substitute in mac and cheese, the cheese sauce is what decides the result, so choose a shape that can hold it and cook the pasta a little under the package time.
A simple method works for most shapes. Cook the pasta in well-salted water until it is just short of tender, drain it, and toss it with the sauce over low heat for a minute or two. That last step lets the pasta absorb some of the cheese without turning soft.
Cupped and ridged shapes need less sauce per piece than smooth tubes, because the sauce collects in the hollows. If you switch from elbow macaroni to small shells or cavatappi, keep the same amount of cheese sauce and check the texture before adding more. A thick sauce may need a splash of the cooking water to loosen it.
When you shop for a macaroni substitute, read the shape name and cook time on the package rather than relying on the name alone. The same shape name can describe slightly different sizes from one brand to another, and that difference is what changes the cook time and the amount of sauce each piece holds.
Baked versions are more forgiving. A casserole can use a longer shape such as spaghetti, broken into short lengths, because the oven softens the noodles and the sauce settles through the dish. Cut the baked pasta into squares for serving.
Does a Macaroni Substitute Change the Flavor?
A macaroni substitute changes the texture more than the flavor, since all dried pasta is made from similar wheat-based dough.
Shapes with ridges give a slightly rougher bite and grip sauce better, while smooth tubes feel softer and slide off a thin sauce. If you want the closest result to classic macaroni, pick a smooth or lightly ridged small shape and cook it to the package time.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use spaghetti instead of macaroni?
Yes, but only in a baked dish. Long spaghetti does not hold a stovetop cheese sauce well, while a baked casserole lets the noodles absorb the sauce and then cut into squares.
Is penne a good macaroni substitute?
Penne is a suitable tube substitute. It is longer and wider than elbow macaroni, so check the package time and test a piece before draining.
Does the shape change the cooking time?
Yes. Shapes of similar size can differ by 4 to 6 minutes, so follow the package time for the shape you actually use and taste a piece a couple of minutes early.
Can I use gnocchi instead of macaroni?
Semolina gnocchi, the dried kind sold in boxes, works in mac and cheese. It is concave and ribbed, so it holds melted cheese well, but it is larger, so plan on fewer pieces per bite.
Small shells, cavatappi and orecchiette cover most macaroni recipes, so start there. Choose a shape with ridges or cups for thick sauces, follow the package time, and pull the pasta a little early if it will finish cooking in the sauce. A close match in size and shape gives the most similar result to the original dish.
6 min readLearnPenne Substitute: 5 Pasta Shapes That Work WellUpdated Nov 13, 2026
5 min readLearnRigatoni Substitute: 4 Pasta Shapes That Work Just as WellUpdated Nov 13, 2026
6 min readLearnRadiatori Substitute: Pasta Shapes That Hold Sauce Like It DoesUpdated Nov 13, 2026
6 min readLearnSpaghetti Substitute: 4 Easy Options That Work With Any SauceUpdated Nov 13, 2026
7 min readLearnMacaroni Pasta: Shapes, Uses and How to Cook ItUpdated Nov 6, 2026
6 min readLearnPasta Dough Cracking? Causes and Fixes That WorkUpdated Nov 13, 2026