Rigatoni Substitute: 4 Pasta Shapes That Work Just as Well
5 min read · by Grace Lin · Last updated: November 13, 2026
The closest rigatoni substitute is mezze rigatoni, followed by penne, ziti and tortiglioni. Each one is a tube or ridged short pasta that holds a chunky sauce, so you can keep the same sauce and the same kind of dish. The main thing to adjust is the sauce: thin, oil-based dressings slide out of wide tubes, so choose a substitute that matches how thick your sauce is.
Rigatoni is a wide, ridged tube with square ends, and it is built for heavy sauces. If your store has run out or your recipe calls for something you do not have, a few shapes come close enough that most people will not notice the difference in the finished dish.
What Makes Rigatoni Different From Other Pasta?
Rigatoni is a semolina tube about 45 to 60 mm long and roughly 16 mm across, with a ridged outside and straight, square-cut ends.
The ridges grip sauce on the outside, and the wide hollow centre holds chunks of meat, sausage or vegetables. The Pasta Almanac entry on rigatoni lists its typical cooking time as 12 to 14 minutes, and it recommends chunky or heavy sauces such as amatriciana, slow meat ragu and baked dishes.

Because so much of rigatoni’s job is holding sauce, the substitute you pick should also be sturdy, hollow or ridged enough to do the same work.
Which Pasta Shapes Work Best as Rigatoni Substitutes?
Mezze rigatoni, penne, ziti and tortiglioni are the four swaps that come up most often, and each one keeps the tube shape that rigatoni uses.
Mezze Rigatoni and Ziti
Mezze rigatoni is the nearest match. It is the same ridged tube cut shorter, so it fits the same spoon and the same baked dish. Ziti is a smooth tube with square ends that is often sold as the baking pasta of southern Italian cooking. It holds sauce well in a casserole, though it has less grip on the outside than rigatoni.
Penne
Penne is the easiest shape to find. Its ends are cut on a diagonal rather than square, which changes how it sits on a fork, but the ridged or smooth tube still holds a meat ragu or tomato sauce. Use penne for baked pasta, pasta bakes and sausage sauces, where the shape matters less than the sauce.
Tortiglioni
Tortiglioni is a tube with spiral ridges. It is a little narrower than rigatoni, and the spiral gives the sauce a lot of grip. It is the best choice when your recipe calls for a thick, clingy sauce such as a slow ragu or a cream-and-cheese bake.
Can Paccheri or Other Big Tubes Replace Rigatoni?
Paccheri is larger than rigatoni and is usually served stuffed or with a very generous sauce, so it is a good swap only in dishes where the pieces can be big. For a standard weeknight sauce it is too large and the sauce does not reach the inside evenly.
Mezze maniche, a short wide ridged tube, is another option for baked dishes and heavy sauces. If you want something that works like rigatoni in a cold pasta salad, a short tube such as fusilli or cavatappi works well because the shape traps dressing and small pieces.
Which Sauces Suit Each Substitute?
Match the thickness of the sauce to the pasta. Thick ragus, sausage sauces and baked cheese sauces suit tubes and spirals. Thin oil-based sauces suit long or flat pasta better, because a hollow tube can trap a lot of the oil and leave the rest of the plate dry.

| Substitute | Shape | Best sauce |
|---|---|---|
| Mezze rigatoni | Short ridged tube | Chunky meat or tomato sauce |
| Penne | Diagonal-cut tube | Baked pasta, sausage sauce |
| Ziti | Smooth tube, square ends | Casseroles and baked dishes |
| Tortiglioni | Spiral-ridged tube | Slow ragu, cream and cheese |
How Should You Cook a Rigatoni Substitute?
Cook the substitute by the time printed on its own package, not by the rigatoni time. Shapes differ in wall thickness and size, so a substitute can finish a minute or two before or after rigatoni. Start tasting a minute before the time on the box and drain when the centre has no chalky white core.
- Salt the water generously and bring it to a full boil before adding the pasta.
- Stir in the pasta in the first minute so the pieces do not stick together.
- Taste from the package time minus one minute and keep checking every minute after that.
- Reserve a cup of the cooking water before draining, and finish the pasta in the sauce for a minute so it grips.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the closest substitute for rigatoni?
Mezze rigatoni is the closest, because it is the same ridged tube in a shorter cut. Penne and ziti are the next best choices and are easy to find in most supermarkets.
Can I use penne instead of rigatoni in baked pasta?
Yes. Penne holds a baked sauce well and works in most casserole recipes. Keep the same sauce amount and bake time as the recipe, then check that the top is hot all the way through.
Is tortiglioni better than penne as a rigatoni swap?
For thick sauces, tortiglioni is often the better match because its spiral ridges grip more sauce. Penne is easier to find and works well in most recipes, so choose whichever you can buy locally.
Should I change the cooking time when I substitute?
Use the time printed on the substitute’s package. Rigatoni usually takes 12 to 14 minutes according to the Pasta Almanac, but other shapes can differ, so check the package rather than copying the rigatoni time.
When you cannot find rigatoni, pick the substitute whose shape matches your sauce: a short ridged tube for chunky ragu, a smooth tube for baked dishes and a spiral for thick cheese or cream sauces. Check the package for cooking time, save some pasta water to loosen the sauce and let the pasta finish in the pan for a minute so every piece is coated.
6 min readLearnPenne Substitute: 5 Pasta Shapes That Work WellUpdated Nov 13, 2026
6 min readLearnSpaghetti Substitute: 4 Easy Options That Work With Any SauceUpdated Nov 13, 2026
6 min readLearnMacaroni Substitute: Best Pasta Shapes That WorkUpdated Nov 13, 2026
9 min readLearnHow to Store Fresh Basil: 4 Easy Methods That WorkUpdated Nov 10, 2026
6 min readLearnRadiatori Substitute: Pasta Shapes That Hold Sauce Like It DoesUpdated Nov 13, 2026
5 min readLearnBest Sauce for Orecchiette: 4 Pairings That Cling to the PastaUpdated Nov 13, 2026