New York Style Pizza Recipe: Dough Ratios, Rise Times and Oven Settings
9 min read · by Grace Lin · Last updated: November 10, 2026
The New York style pizza recipe comes down to three things: a bread flour dough, a long cold rise, and a very hot steel or stone. Two published recipes use the same method with different weights, so the exact ratios matter. This guide to the New York style pizza recipe lays out both sets of numbers so you can pick the one that fits your oven and your batch size.
Both recipes use the same core ingredients, which are bread flour, water, salt and yeast, with a small amount of sugar and oil added. Once you see the weights side by side, the differences in hydration and yield are easy to spot.
New York Style Pizza Recipe Ingredients and Ratios
A New York style pizza recipe starts with about 360 g of bread flour and 206 g of water in King Arthur’s version, or 872 g of flour and 567 g of water in Ooni’s version.

The two doughs are close in method but not in weight. King Arthur’s dough carries about 57 percent water relative to flour, while Ooni’s carries about 65 percent, which makes a wetter and stickier dough. Both percentages are calculated from the gram weights each page lists, because neither page gives baker’s percentages directly.
| Ingredient | King Arthur | Ooni |
|---|---|---|
| Bread flour | 360 g | 872 g |
| Water | 206 g, cool at 60 to 70 F | 567 g |
| Water as share of flour (calculated) | About 57% | About 65% |
| Salt | 12 g table salt | 26 g kosher salt |
| Sugar | 12 g | 9 g |
| Oil | 12 g vegetable oil | 44 g extra-virgin olive oil |
| Yeast | 1/4 tsp instant yeast (weight not listed) | 2 g active dry yeast, or 1 1/4 g instant |
| Yield | Two 13-inch pizzas from two pieces of about 300 g | Four balls of 380 g for 16-inch pizzas |
Use the weights from one New York style pizza recipe as a complete set. If you scale a batch, change the flour, water and salt together so the ratio stays the same. King Arthur does not give a gram weight for its yeast, so measure that by the teaspoon and check the package for the amount per batch.

Mixing, Folding and the First Rest
Mix the dough for this New York style pizza recipe until it comes together, then give it a rest with either folds or a one-hour pause before dividing. The method is simple, but the rest time is what lets the flour fully absorb the water.
King Arthur’s New York style recipe combines the flour, sugar, salt and yeast in one bowl, then adds the oil and water. It asks you to knead by hand until the dough is rough but cohesive, then cover it and let it rest at room temperature for 1 hour.
Ooni’s version takes a more hands-on route with a stand mixer. Mix on the lowest speed until the dough comes together, which the page puts at about 5 to 10 minutes, then knead by hand for about 10 minutes. The page also describes a fold cycle, with a fold after the first hour and another rest of one hour between each fold.
- Combine the dry ingredients, then add the oil and water, following King Arthur’s order.
- Knead until rough but cohesive, then rest for 1 hour at room temperature.
- Fold the dough after the first hour, rest it one more hour, and repeat for three folds in total, following Ooni’s method.
Neither page gives a dough temperature during mixing, so the water temperature is the only temperature control in the first stage. King Arthur specifies cool water at 60 to 70 F, which keeps the dough from warming too fast during kneading.
Cold Fermentation and Dough Balls
Ooni’s recipe cold proofs the dough overnight for 16 to 52 hours, until it has roughly doubled in size. The wide window reflects how much the rise depends on your fridge and how warm your kitchen is.

After the folds, Ooni divides the dough into four balls of 380 g each. The page lists these for four 16-inch pizzas, although in one place it gives the base as 36 cm and in another as 40 cm. Refrigerate the balls in a dough box or on a sheet tray, then take them out 3 hours before cooking.
King Arthur uses a shorter path. After dividing the dough into two pieces of about 300 g, you rest them at room temperature for 8 to 10 hours. The page also allows refrigerating the dough for up to 3 days, and it asks that refrigerated dough rest at room temperature for at least 1 hour while the oven preheats.
The cold rise gives you flexibility with any New York style pizza recipe. You can mix in the morning and bake in the evening, or make the dough a day ahead and bring it up to room temperature before you shape it.
Preheating the Oven or Steel to Baking Temperature
King Arthur preheats the oven to 500 F for at least one hour, while Ooni heats its stone to 750 F, measured with an infrared thermometer. Both versions of the New York style pizza recipe rely on a steel or stone sitting on the lower rack before the pie goes in.
Ooni’s gas oven method runs the burner on maximum for at least 30 minutes, then turns it to low for about 5 minutes until the stone reaches 750 F. King Arthur’s oven stays at 500 F, and the pie spends most of its time on the stone before it moves under the broiler.
Home ovens vary, and a New York style pizza recipe depends on reaching heat, so read about pizza baking temperatures in a home oven. Check your oven manual for its maximum temperature, whether the broiler can be used with a stone on the rack, and how long the stone needs to reach full heat. Those limits decide which of the two settings you can actually hit for a New York style pizza recipe at home.
Stretching, Topping and Baking the Pie
Bake the pie on the hot stone for about 5 minutes, then finish under the broiler, which gives King Arthur’s recipe a total bake of 7 to 10 minutes. Ooni’s gas method is quicker, at 4 to 5 minutes in total.
Stretch each piece by hand for your New York style pizza recipe into a round, keeping the edge a little thicker than the center so the rim can puff. Add a light layer of sauce and cheese, because a heavy topping slows the base from crisping.
- Slide the stretched pie onto the hot steel or stone and bake for 5 minutes.
- If the bottom is not spotted and charred, rotate the pie and bake 1 to 2 minutes more.
- Move the pie to the top rack, switch to broil, and cook for 2 to 3 minutes.
For Ooni’s gas method, launch the pie, turn the flame off for 2 minutes, then return it to low for 2 to 3 more minutes. The two bake times differ, so watch the crust color rather than the clock if you switch between recipes.
Common Mistakes With a New York Style Pizza Recipe
In any New York style pizza recipe, a stone that has not fully preheated leaves the bottom pale and soft, even when the dough is right. Give the stone the full preheat time listed in the recipe you follow.
Yield is the other trap. King Arthur’s dough makes two 13-inch pizzas, while Ooni’s makes four 380 g balls for 16-inch pies. Mixing the two recipes can leave you with too little dough for the pan you own, so pick one set and match the pie size to it.
- Skipping the rest in a New York style pizza recipe, which gives the flour less time to absorb the water.
- Piling toppings onto a thin base, which keeps the center soggy.
- Baking on a stone that has not reached the target temperature.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use all-purpose flour in a New York style pizza recipe?
Both recipes here call for bread flour, which is the flour the weights were written for. Check the protein content on the package before you substitute. A swap is your own test, so the crust may come out differently from the published versions. This look at bread flour versus all-purpose flour in pizza dough covers the trade-offs.
How many pizzas does one batch make?
King Arthur’s dough yields two 13-inch pizzas from about 600 g of dough. Ooni’s makes four balls of 380 g each, which the page lists for 16-inch pizzas. Divide the batch for your New York style pizza recipe by the pizza size you plan to bake.
Do I need a pizza steel or stone?
Both recipes preheat a steel or stone on the lower rack, and King Arthur asks for at least one hour of preheating. Without one, you can still follow the steps, but the bottom crust will not match the published results. For help picking one, see this baking steel buying and care guide.
How long can the dough stay in the fridge?
King Arthur says refrigerated dough can keep for up to 3 days, and it should rest at room temperature for at least 1 hour before baking. Ooni’s cold proof runs 16 to 52 hours, so check whether the dough has roughly doubled rather than relying on the clock alone. For a broader look at storage, see how long pizza dough keeps in the fridge.
Is sugar necessary in a New York style pizza recipe?
Both recipes include a small amount of sugar, 12 g in King Arthur’s version and 9 g in Ooni’s. Neither source explains its role in detail, so keep the weight from the recipe you follow when you test a batch.
If you want the easier-handling dough, start with King Arthur’s version at about 57 percent water. If your oven can reach a stone at 750 F and you are ready for a wetter dough, try Ooni’s version. Either way, run one full batch of this New York style pizza recipe with a single set of weights before you change anything.
8 min readLearnNew York Style vs Sicilian Pizza: Crust, Shape and Cheese ComparedUpdated Nov 7, 2026
8 min readLearnNew York Style vs Detroit Style Pizza: How They DifferUpdated Nov 14, 2026
8 min readLearnNeapolitan vs New York Style Pizza: How They DifferUpdated Nov 14, 2026
9 min readLearnWhat Is New York Style Pizza? A Simple Guide for Home CooksUpdated Nov 7, 2026
8 min readLearnNeapolitan Pizza Dough Recipe: Ratios, Mixing and RiseUpdated Nov 10, 2026
8 min readLearnCalzone Recipe: Dough, Filling and Bake Times for Home and Pizza OvensUpdated Nov 10, 2026