New York Style vs Sicilian Pizza: Crust, Shape and Cheese Compared
8 min read · by Grace Lin · Last updated: November 7, 2026
New York style vs Sicilian pizza comes down to crust, shape and cheese: New York pies are large, thin and foldable, while Sicilian pies are thick and often rectangular. New York style grew out of pizza made by Italian immigrants in the early 1900s. Sicilian pizza comes from Sicily and reached North America with a thicker crust and a rectangular shape.
Choose by the slice you want to eat: a thin one you can fold, or a thick, cheesy one you eat with a fork and knife.
| Pick | Best for | Key fact |
|---|---|---|
| New York style | Thin slices you can fold and eat by hand | Crust is thick only at the edge, with a thin base beneath the toppings |
| Sicilian pizza | Thick, cheesy pies cut into rectangular pieces | The American version has dough over an inch thick |
New York Style vs Sicilian Pizza: Quick Comparison
New York style vs Sicilian pizza differs most in shape and crust: New York style is large, thin and foldable, while Sicilian is typically thicker, often rectangular and commonly topped with strong cheeses.
| Feature | New York style | Sicilian pizza |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | Italian immigrants in New York, early 1900s | Sicily, Italy |
| Shape | Large and hand-tossed, typically 18 to 24 inches across | Often rectangular, though it can also be round |
| Crust | Thick only at the edge, thin and pliable beneath the toppings | Over an inch thick in the American version |
| Cheese | Dry, grated, full-fat mozzarella | Strong cheeses such as caciocavallo and toma are common |
| Eating | Folded for eating, often sold as wide slices to go | Not described as foldable in the sources reviewed |
The table reflects the sources checked for this article. Each section below covers one row of the new york style vs sicilian pizza comparison.
Where Each Style Came From
New York style developed in the early 1900s from pizza made by Italian immigrants, particularly Neapolitans, while Sicilian pizza comes from the island of Sicily.
Wikipedia’s New York-style pizza article traces the style to Neapolitan immigrants who made pizza in New York (our what is New York style pizza page has the basics). Lombardi’s in Little Italy is said to have been founded in 1905 by Gennaro Lombardi, although author Peter Regas has challenged that date. In 1924, Antonio Totonno Pero, an early employee there, left to open Totonno’s on Coney Island. By 2010, over 400 pizza restaurants existed in New York City.
Sicilian pizza was popular in western Sicily by the mid-19th century (start with what Sicilian pizza is if the name is new to you). It reached North America in an altered form, with a thicker crust and a rectangular shape, which is the version many American readers picture when they say Sicilian pizza. Its roots matter for new york style vs sicilian pizza because the American form changed the original.
Sicily also has regional versions that differ from the American style, and Sicilian pizza itself is often compared with Roman and Neapolitan pies, as in Roman vs Sicilian pizza. Sfincione, a common variety, originated in the province of Palermo. Other examples include:
- Syracuse: pizzolu, a round stuffed pizza
- Catania: scacciata, topped with toma and anchovies in the city
- Messina: piduni, a calzone with endive, tomato, cheese and anchovies
Crust Thickness and Dough
New York crust is thin under the toppings and crisp only at the edge, while the American version of Sicilian pizza has dough over an inch thick. That gap is the core of new york style vs sicilian pizza.

The distinctive New York crust comes from high-gluten bread flour, according to Wikipedia’s article on the style. Minerals in New York City tap water are also credited with the texture and flavor of local dough, so a home version made with other water may taste different. The flour is the main reason new york style vs sicilian pizza crusts feel so different.
The thin base is what lets a New York slice stay pliable enough to fold. Sicilian pizza takes the opposite trade-off: more dough in every bite, and a crust that the sources reviewed do not describe as foldable. Detroit pizza sits at the thick end too, and our New York and Detroit style comparison shows how it differs from the thin, foldable New York slice.
The sources reviewed do not give hydration, flour percentage or oven temperature for either style. For the thick-pan side, our Detroit style vs Sicilian pizza comparison is a useful next read, and Neapolitan vs Sicilian pizza covers the thin-crust contrast. Check a tested recipe for those numbers instead of copying them from a general guide.
Shape, Size and Slices
New York pies are typically 18 to 24 inches across and commonly cut into eight slices, while traditional Sicilian pizza is often thick-crusted and rectangular. Shape is the fastest way to tell new york style vs sicilian pizza apart.
The Sicilian pizza article on Wikipedia describes the thick, rectangular form as traditional but not the only one, since Sicilian pizza can also be round and similar to Neapolitan pizza. New York slices are often sold as wide slices to go, and the crust folds for eating.
Sfincione is typically rectangular, which is why the rectangular shape is the best-known Sicilian format. Use the shape you want as a starting point:
- New York style suits a pie you can fold, in a round format about 18 to 24 inches across.
- Sicilian style suits a rectangular pie with a deep bread base.
- Skip New York style if your goal is a thick, bready slice.
Toppings and Cheese
The basic New York pie uses a light layer of tomato sauce and dry, grated, full-fat mozzarella under the other toppings, while Sicilian pizza commonly uses strong cheeses such as caciocavallo and toma.

In sfincione, the sauce is sometimes placed over the toppings. Sfincione also uses less cheese than a Neapolitan pizza, and some Sicilian versions have no cheese at all.
Traditional Sicilian toppings include tomatoes, herbs, onions, anchovies and strong cheese. Cheese is the second big difference in new york style vs sicilian pizza. Strong cheese gives the pie a bold flavor, but a New York style with lighter cheese is the easier choice if you want to fold the slice.
Which Style Should You Make at Home?
Choose New York style for a thin, foldable slice and Sicilian for a thick, cheesy, rectangular pie.
Your choice of new york style vs sicilian pizza depends on the slice you want at the end. A New York pie needs a base that stays thin under the toppings, while a Sicilian pie needs enough dough to hold a thick, rectangular shape:
- Pick New York style if you want slices eaten by hand.
- Pick Sicilian style if you want a thick base with strong cheese.
- Read the scope of each style before you buy equipment, since the sources reviewed do not cover every restaurant or regional version.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Sicilian pizza always rectangular?
Not always. Traditional Sicilian pizza is often thick-crusted and rectangular, but it can also be round and similar to Neapolitan pizza. Sfincione, a common Sicilian variety from the Palermo area, is typically rectangular.
Where does sfincione come from?
Sfincione originated in the province of Palermo on the island of Sicily. It is typically rectangular and uses less cheese than a Neapolitan pizza, and its sauce is sometimes placed over the toppings.
What flour gives New York pizza its crust?
The distinctive New York crust comes from high-gluten bread flour, according to Wikipedia’s article on the style. Minerals in New York City tap water are also credited with the local dough’s texture and flavor.
How thick is American Sicilian pizza?
The American version of Sicilian pizza has dough over an inch thick, according to the Sicilian pizza article on Wikipedia. That thickness is the main difference in new york style vs sicilian pizza.
Do Sicilian pizzas always have cheese?
No. Some versions of Sicilian pizza have no cheese, according to the Sicilian pizza article on Wikipedia. When cheese is used, strong cheeses such as caciocavallo and toma are common. That detail is useful when you weigh new york style vs sicilian pizza cheese choices.
When you compare new york style vs sicilian pizza, pick New York style if you want a slice you can fold and eat by hand, and pick Sicilian if you want a thick, cheesy, rectangular pie. Crust and cheese decide the result more than the toppings do. Before you start, compare recipes for dough hydration and oven settings, since the sources reviewed here do not give those figures.
9 min readLearnNeapolitan vs Sicilian Pizza: Shape, Crust and Baking ComparedUpdated Nov 7, 2026
8 min readLearnNew York Style vs Detroit Style Pizza: How They DifferUpdated Nov 14, 2026
8 min readLearnNeapolitan vs New York Style Pizza: How They DifferUpdated Nov 14, 2026
9 min readLearnWhat Is New York Style Pizza? A Simple Guide for Home CooksUpdated Nov 7, 2026
9 min readLearnNew York Style Pizza Recipe: Dough Ratios, Rise Times and Oven SettingsUpdated Nov 10, 2026
7 min readLearnRoman vs Sicilian Pizza: Dough, Thickness and Pan ComparedUpdated Nov 7, 2026