Anchovy Pizza Recipe: How to Make It at Home
8 min read · by Grace Lin · Last updated: November 11, 2026
An anchovy pizza recipe is simple: a thin dough base, a light layer of sauce or onion, salty anchovy fillets and a very hot bake. Anchovies carry most of the flavor, so keep the other toppings light and let them stand out.
What Does an Anchovy Pizza Taste Like?
An anchovy pizza tastes salty and savory, because curing gives anchovies a strong flavor that fresh fish does not have. Fresh anchovies are much milder, but most home recipes use cured fillets.
Wikipedia’s anchovy entry explains that the strong taste comes from the curing process. The fish are gutted, salted in brine, cured and then packed in oil or salt. Fresh anchovies, called alici in Italy, have a much milder flavor.
That contrast shapes the whole anchovy pizza recipe. Anchovies, olives and tomato also come together in the puttanesca sauce recipe, a useful flavor reference. A salty fish pairs well with mild sweet onion, a little melted cheese and one briny extra such as olives. When the topping list gets long, the anchovy flavor gets lost under the other ingredients.
Choose and Prepare the Anchovies
Buy anchovy fillets packed in olive oil for your anchovy pizza recipe (see our guide to the best canned anchovies), then drain them well before they go on the dough. Excess oil and moisture soften the crust, so drying the fillets is the step that matters most.

Oil-packed fillets are the simplest choice for an anchovy pizza recipe in a home oven. DeLallo’s anchovy pizza recipe uses 10 fillets in olive oil, drained, for the whole batch, since its dough is cut in half to make two pizzas. Olive Magazine’s version uses 25 g of anchovies, so the amount depends on how many pizzas you make and how strong you want the topping.
Prepare the fillets in this order:
- Open the tin or jar and lift the fillets out with a fork, leaving the oil behind.
- Lay them on kitchen paper and let them drain until they stop dripping.
- Blot the tops dry so no oil pools on the sauce or cheese.
- Place them on the pizza just before it goes into the oven. For layering order, see the pizza toppings order guide.
Olive Magazine’s recipe does not say whether its anchovies are salted or oil-packed, and it does not mention rinsing. Check the label before you buy. Salted anchovies need rinsing and drying before use, and the product label gives the method for its own packing.
Olives add a mild, briny contrast that suits an anchovy pizza recipe well. Olive Magazine uses 50 g of olives, and many recipes use pitted black or Kalamata olives. Capers can add a similar salty note, but none of the sources reviewed for this guide gave an amount for them.
Make the Base and the Toppings
For a home anchovy pizza recipe, use a yeast dough, either a kit or homemade, let it rise until doubled, then top it with a thin layer of sauce, mozzarella and a light scattering of onion. The base should be thin enough that the anchovies are not buried.

DeLallo’s recipe mixes its dough kit with lukewarm water, kneads it by hand for 3 minutes, and then lets it rise in a warm place for about 45 minutes until doubled. The dough can also be refrigerated for 1 to 3 days after rising, which helps when you want to plan ahead.
Olive Magazine takes a slower route. It mixes a pre-ferment the night before from 150 g bread flour, 150 ml tepid water and a quarter teaspoon of fast-action yeast, and leaves it covered overnight. The next day, the pre-ferment is mixed with 300 g bread flour, 120 ml warm water, half a teaspoon of yeast and 2 teaspoons of sea salt, then kneaded and left to rise for 1 to 2 hours until doubled. That dough is divided into four balls, so one batch makes four anchovy pizza bases. For stretching tips, see how to stretch pizza dough.
DeLallo’s recipe lists these toppings for its batch of two pizzas:
- Half a cup of crushed tomatoes, spread as a thin layer.
- Five ounces of fresh mozzarella, torn into pieces.
- One cup of shredded provolone.
- Ten anchovy fillets in olive oil, drained.
- A handful of oil-cured olives and a handful of fresh basil after baking.
Caramelized Onion Option
Olive Magazine builds its topping on onions rather than tomato. Melt 30 g of butter, then cook 6 finely sliced onions with 2 chopped garlic cloves and 4 to 5 sprigs of thyme over medium-low heat for 45 minutes to 1 hour until caramelized. Spread about 3 tablespoons of the onions over each base before adding the anchovies and olives.
Anchovy Pizza Recipe: Bake It Hot
Bake the pizza at 500°F for 12 to 15 minutes until the crust is golden, according to DeLallo’s anchovy pizza recipe. Preheat the oven fully before the pizza goes in, so the base starts cooking the moment it touches the hot surface.
DeLallo’s anchovy pizza recipe adds the anchovies and olives after the cheese, then bakes until the crust is golden. DeLallo’s method adds fresh basil after the pizza comes out of the oven.
Olive Magazine cooks its bases differently. It heats an oiled frying pan until very hot, cooks each base for 5 to 6 minutes until puffy, then moves the pizza under a high grill for 3 to 5 minutes until the topping bubbles and turns slightly charred. That recipe does not give an oven temperature, so use the pan and grill times as written.
Finish an Olive Magazine style anchovy pizza recipe with a drizzle of thyme honey. Melt 4 tablespoons of honey with 3 sprigs of thyme, then spoon it over the cooked pizza. The sweetness balances the salt in the anchovies.
The two anchovy pizza recipes differ in method more than in ingredients, so the table below shows where each one is specific and where it stays silent.
| Step | DeLallo recipe | Olive Magazine recipe |
|---|---|---|
| Anchovies | 10 fillets in olive oil, drained (whole batch of two) | 25 g anchovies, salted or oil-packed not stated |
| Olives | A handful of oil-cured olives | 50 g olives |
| Cheese | 5 oz fresh mozzarella and 1 cup shredded provolone | No cheese used |
| Dough rise | About 45 minutes until doubled | 1 to 2 hours after a pre-ferment made overnight |
| Cooking | 500°F for 12 to 15 minutes | Pan 5 to 6 minutes, then high grill 3 to 5 minutes |
For a first anchovy pizza recipe, the DeLallo method is easier to follow because it gives a single oven setting and a short bake. If you have a pizza oven or a very hot grill and want a crisper base, the Olive Magazine pan and grill steps are a good model to adapt.
Common Mistakes With Anchovy Pizza
The most common mistake in any anchovy pizza recipe is putting wet anchovies on the dough, which steams the base instead of crisping it. Drain and blot the fillets before they touch the pizza, and read our guide to fixing soggy pizza if the center still stays wet.
Watch for these problems with an anchovy pizza recipe:
- Skipping the draining step, so the oil runs into the cheese.
- Piling on onion or cheese, which keeps the center soft.
- Adding extra salt before tasting, since the anchovies and olives already bring plenty.
- Baking in a cool oven, which dries the crust before the cheese melts.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do you rinse anchovies before putting them on pizza?
For an anchovy pizza recipe, oil-packed fillets only need draining and blotting. Salted anchovies need rinsing and drying, and the product label should tell you which kind you have before you start.
Can you use salted anchovies on pizza?
Yes, but they need preparation first. Rinse them under cold water, dry them on kitchen paper and then check the saltiness before you add other salt to the pizza.
What oven temperature should an anchovy pizza bake at?
DeLallo’s recipe uses 500°F for 12 to 15 minutes until the crust is golden. Olive Magazine’s method uses a very hot pan and a high grill rather than a temperature setting.
How many anchovies go on one anchovy pizza recipe?
DeLallo’s recipe uses 10 drained fillets for its two pizzas, which is about 5 per pizza, and Olive Magazine uses 25 g of anchovies in its whole recipe. Start with about 5 fillets for a single pizza, then add more if you want a stronger salty note in your anchovy pizza recipe.
Should anchovy pizza have tomato sauce?
Not always. DeLallo’s version uses crushed tomatoes, while Olive Magazine’s version uses only caramelized onion, garlic and thyme. Choose the base that you prefer for your anchovy pizza recipe and keep the layer thin.
A simple anchovy pizza recipe works best when the fish is drained well and the rest of the toppings stay light. Try the tomato version first, then switch to the onion base if you want a sweeter result. Check the anchovy label before you buy, so you know whether you are working with oil-packed or salted fillets.
7 min readLearnWhat Is Colatura di Alici? Italy’s Anchovy Drip SauceUpdated Nov 11, 2026
9 min readLearnZucchini Pizza Recipe: Two Easy Ways to Make It at HomeUpdated Nov 11, 2026
7 min readLearnSalsiccia e Friarielli Pizza Recipe: How to Make It at HomeUpdated Nov 11, 2026
8 min readLearnStuffed Crust Pizza Recipe: How to Make a Cheese-Filled Rim at HomeUpdated Nov 11, 2026
8 min readLearnDairy Free Pizza Recipe: How to Make It at HomeUpdated Nov 12, 2026
8 min readLearnPizza Al Taglio Recipe: Roman Sheet-Pan Pizza You Can Make at HomeUpdated Nov 10, 2026